TMZ Live 1/31/13: Beyonce Goes Live ... but Way Too Far to Prove Her Point

Beyonce sticks it to the haters -- belting out the National Anthem ... LIVE! No doubt she can sing, but did the move seem a little desperate? Plus, San Francisco 49er Chris Culliver made horribly homophobic comments -- but his apology might have actually made it worse! Now, the question is will the team let him skate and play in the Super Bowl? And, Supermodel Bar Refaeli says she wants to talk to dorky dudes at bars in order to make their day -- and she's totally right! Except in Harvey's eyes.

Click here for info about our online advertising practices.